Medical Negligence*

Medical Negligence

Medical negligence*

Medical Negligence*

In many ways, medical negligence cases can be seen as a sub branch of Personal Injuries cases. In very general terms, the liability question in medical negligence cases is measured as to whether the medical professional acted within the level of competence of another equivalent medical professional.


The landmark decision in this area derives from the 1989 case Dunne v The National Maternity Hospital. This sets out the test for establishing negligence in diagnosis or treatment on the part of a medical practitioner. Broadly this is whether the practitioner has been guilty of such failures as no medical practitioner of equal specialist or general status and skill would be guilty of if acting with ordinary care. Unlike personal injury matters, medical negligence cases are not submitted to the Personal Injuries Assessment Board and proceedings can be issued without delay once the appropriate reports have been obtained. The issue of quantum is dealt with in much the same way and by applying the same principles as a personal injury case.

How we can help
For every case of this nature we will select an appropriate expert to compile a report examining the issue of medical negligence. To preserve independence, the specialist will often be a UK based consultant. Our first step in instructing the specialist will be to furnish him or her with your complete set of medical notes. If the report is in your favour, we are then permitted by the rules of professional conduct to write to the offending party on your behalf seeking an admission of liability.

* In contentious business, a solicitor may not calculate fees or other charges as a percentage or proportion of any award or settlement


What Our Clients
Say About Us

All testimonials

Philip is a pleasure to deal with, very professional and leaves no stone unturned, highly recommend Philip for any legal matters.

David Shanaghy

It was a pleasure to use Philip Vint as my solicitor recently! Having used other solicitors in the area I would highly recommend him over the others! Very professional with excellent communication throughout the process. A very pleasant man also.

Gareth Robinson

I had the great pleasure in using Philip’s services as a solicitor recently. I’ve used various solicitors over the years and Philip stands out as being the best experience I’ve ever had with one. Besides being excellent at his job, he explained everything in terms I could understand, there was no hidden fee’s and was very clear on what costs were involved. His dedication, excellent communication and knowledge of the issues around my legal needs seriously impressed me. He gave me great peace of mind in dealing with my legal issue and I can highly recommend him if you need a solicitor. Many thanks Philip.

Frainc Harrington

I received brilliant support from Philip Vint & Co solicitors following a road traffic accident. The quality of knowledge and friendliness of staff was exceptional. Philip provided advice and good communication throughout my claim. I would gladly recommend Philip Vint & Co solicitors.

Grace R, Dublin

I had an accident on my motorbike which I did not cause. I only had 3rd party insurance and was told by both my own and the other person’s insurance company to go away. I knew this was wrong. A friend recommended Philip Vint to me. Philip understood what I was going through and sorted it all out.

Peter S, Graiguecullen

put our experience and
energy to work for you!


contact us

Get in touch


73 Burrin Street, Carlow


(059) 91 64363

Philip Vint & Co. Solicitors

These are extracts from testimonials:
‘Professional, thorough & helpful…
Clarity, patience & meticulous attention…
Prompt, precise, polite…
A pleasure to deal with…’

Philip Vint & Co. Solicitors © 2018 All rights reserved. Cookie Policy and Privacy Policy

Scroll to top